Part A: Costs
Management accounting concepts
Key takeaways
- Management accounting identifies, measures, analyses and communicates financial and operating information so managers can plan, control and make decisions; cost accounting is the part of it that records and reports costs.
- Unlike financial accounting, management accounting is not required by law, has no prescribed format, looks forward as well as back, and accepts timely estimates over precise figures.
- A cost centre accumulates and controls costs, a profit centre answers for both revenue and costs, and each is a responsibility centre whose manager is held accountable.
- Cost control keeps actual spending within an accepted standard or budget, continuously; cost reduction permanently lowers the cost itself without impairing quality.
- One cost can be classified several ways at once, by function, behaviour, nature, relation to the cost unit, time, relevance to a decision and production method, so read which basis a question asks for.
Management accounting turns the same underlying transactions financial accounting records into information built for a different reader, managers, running the business day to day, rather than outsiders assessing it after the fact. This chapter fixes the vocabulary and boundaries of that field.
Key terms
Role of management accounting
- Providing information for planning, both short-term budgets and long-term strategy
- Supporting control, by comparing actual performance against a plan or standard
- Informing specific decisions such as pricing, product mix and make-or-buy choices (see the chapter on break-even analysis)
- Motivating managers and employees through the targets a budget or standard sets
- Evaluating performance of individuals, departments and the organisation as a whole
- Communicating organisational objectives down through the management structure
Users of management accounting information
Management versus financial accounting
| Management accounting | Financial accounting | |
|---|---|---|
| Primary users | Internal managers | External stakeholders (investors, lenders, tax authorities) |
| Legal requirement | Not required by law | Required by the Companies Act and tax law |
| Time orientation | Forward-looking (plans, budgets, forecasts) as well as historical | Historical, reports on a period already ended |
| Format | No prescribed format, tailored to management's need | Prescribed by accounting standards (IFRS) |
| Reporting frequency | As often as management needs, daily, weekly or monthly | Usually annual, with interim reports for some entities |
| Precision | Estimates and approximations are acceptable if timely | Requires greater accuracy and verifiability |
Cost accounting and management accounting
Cost accounting is a subset of management accounting: it supplies the detailed cost data (per product, per department, per activity) that management accounting then analyses, interprets and presents for planning, control and decision making. Every cost accounting report is potentially useful to management accounting, but management accounting also draws on non-cost information, market data, non-financial performance measures, that cost accounting alone does not provide.
Limitations of management accounting
- Based substantially on historical cost data, which may not reflect current replacement values
- Relies on estimates and forecasts, which can prove inaccurate
- Lacks a single prescribed format, making comparison between organisations difficult
- Can be costly and time-consuming to maintain in detail
- Its recommendations are only as good as the judgement of the manager interpreting them
- Does not replace, only supplements, other management skills and experience
Cost control and cost reduction
Definitions
Advantages of cost control
- Keeps actual spending aligned with the budget, protecting profitability
- Highlights variances early enough for corrective action to matter
- Encourages departmental accountability for spending
- Supports realistic future budgeting, since it shows where past estimates held or failed
Control versus reduction
| Cost control | Cost reduction | |
|---|---|---|
| Nature | Regulatory, keeps cost within a set target | Corrective, permanently lowers the target itself |
| Approach | Continuous, ongoing monitoring | One-off or periodic improvement projects |
| Assumption about the standard | Assumes the current standard/budget is acceptable | Challenges whether the current cost level is the lowest achievable |
| Emphasis | Preventing costs from exceeding a plan | Finding a genuinely lower cost while maintaining quality |
Choosing a cost accounting system
What a cost accounting system is
A cost accounting system is the set of procedures and records an organisation uses to accumulate, classify and report the cost of its products, services or activities.
Design factors
- Nature of the business and its production or service process
- Organisational structure and the size of the business
- The cost of operating the system relative to the benefit it provides
- Management's specific information needs
- Flexibility to adapt as the business changes
- Compatibility with existing financial accounting records
Professional ethics
A management accountant, like any accounting professional, is bound by a code of ethics; four principles recur across professional bodies' codes.
Cost classification
What cost classification is
Cost classification is the process of grouping costs according to their common characteristics, so they can be analysed and reported in whichever way best serves a given management purpose.
Why costs are classified
- Determining the cost of a product, job or service (see the chapter on costing methods)
- Planning and preparing budgets (see the chapter on budgeting)
- Controlling costs by comparing actual against budgeted or standard cost
- Supporting specific management decisions (see the chapter on break-even analysis)
Bases of classification
The same cost can be classified in several different ways at once, depending on what question is being asked of it.
- Fixed costs: unchanged in total as activity varies.
- Variable costs: change in direct proportion to activity.
- Semi-variable (mixed) costs: a fixed element plus a variable element, which the cost estimation techniques of the next chapter exist specifically to split.
- Direct: traceable in full to a specific cost unit, direct material and direct labour.
- Indirect/overhead: not traceable to one specific cost unit, and so shared across several, covered under overheads in the chapter on accounting for materials, labour and overheads.
Exam tip
A single cost, factory rent, say, is simultaneously an overhead (relation to cost unit), a fixed cost (behaviour), and a production or administration cost (function) depending on which classification a question is asking about. Read the question's classification basis carefully before answering.
Self-check
(a) Distinguish a cost centre from a profit centre. (3 marks)
(b) Classify factory rent under: (i) behaviour; (ii) relation to cost unit; (iii) function. (3 marks)
(c) Distinguish cost control from cost reduction. (4 marks)
(d) State two limitations of management accounting. (2 marks)
Show worked answer
(a) A cost centre is a location, function or item of equipment for which costs are accumulated and separately controlled; a profit centre is a segment whose manager is accountable for both the revenue it earns and the costs it incurs, and therefore for its profit (3 marks).
(b) (i) Fixed cost; (ii) overhead/indirect cost, since it cannot be traced to one specific cost unit; (iii) typically a production or administration cost, depending on which part of the business occupies the space (3 marks).
(c) Cost control is the continuous process of regulating actual costs against a predetermined standard or budget, to keep spending within an accepted level; cost reduction is a deliberate, planned effort to permanently lower the cost itself without impairing quality, a one-off improvement rather than an ongoing regulatory activity (4 marks).
(d) Any two of: based substantially on historical cost data; relies on estimates and forecasts that can prove inaccurate; lacks a single prescribed format, making comparison difficult; can be costly and time-consuming to maintain in detail (2 marks).